The numbers out this week don’t seem to agree with each other. Realtor.com’s November 16 weekly outlook put active listings at 1.59 million homes, a 5.1 month supply, tied with the high from November 2015. At the same time, NAR reported October existing home sales at a 3.75 million annual pace, the slowest in 16 years, down 5.5 percent from September and 8.8 percent from a year ago. Freddie Mac’s 30 year average fell to 7.11 percent on November 12, the fourth straight weekly decline, down from 6.24 percent a year ago.
More homes for sale than we’ve seen in a decade. Fewer homes selling than we’ve seen in 16 years. Those two facts are not a contradiction. They’re the same story told from two different angles.
What 5.1 Months of Supply Actually Means
I want to clear something up first, because I think a lot of people are reading this inventory number wrong.
For decades, the real estate industry has used six months of supply as the line between a buyer’s market and a seller’s market. Below six months, sellers have the advantage because there isn’t enough inventory to meet demand. Above six months, buyers have the advantage because there’s more product than buyers to absorb it.
At 5.1 months, we’re still technically on the seller’s side of that line. We have not tipped into a buyer’s market by the traditional definition. What we have done is climb back toward a historically normal, balanced market after years of being stuck at one or two months of supply during the pandemic years, which was never sustainable or healthy for anyone.
The media tends to cover any increase in inventory like it’s a warning sign. It isn’t. It’s the market doing what it’s supposed to do after being artificially starved of homes for sale for far too long. Calling 5.1 months of supply a crisis is like calling a fever of 98.6 a medical emergency because it used to run at 103.
More Choice Is Not the Same as More Affordable
Here’s where the real story is. Buyers now have more homes to choose from, more room to negotiate repairs, more sellers willing to offer a credit, and in some cases, actual price reductions. That’s genuine leverage, and it’s worth using if you’re shopping right now.
But none of that changes what the house actually costs each month. A seller offering a two percent credit on a home you can’t comfortably afford at 7.11 percent is still a home you can’t comfortably afford. More listings on a website doesn’t lower your payment. It just gives you more chances to find a house where the payment and the home actually line up.
That’s why existing home sales are at a 16 year low even with more inventory sitting on the market than we’ve had in a decade. Buyers are looking. A lot of them are deciding the math still doesn’t work.
Why Rates Are Higher Than They Should Be
I’ve heard a theory floated by more than one person in this industry that part of the reason mortgage rates run higher than the underlying bond market would suggest comes down to guarantee fees charged by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Those fees get built into the rate you’re quoted, and the theory goes that they’ve climbed since the financial crisis because federal regulators have required the agencies to hold more capital in reserve, to protect against another mortgage meltdown down the road.
I don’t have hard data to back up an exact number, and I want to be upfront about that. One source was a verbal talk I heard roughly a year ago from an economist who admitted even he had a hard time pinning down the precise figure. Another was the owner of a mortgage company with around 200 loan officers across several states, who backed up the general idea but only described it as several basis points of padding, not a specific amount.
So take this as a theory worth understanding, not a confirmed number. The rate you’re quoted is never just the Fed, and it’s never just the 10 year Treasury. There are layers of cost built into that number that most buyers never hear explained, and the agencies passing along the cost of their own capital requirements may be part of that picture.
The Affordability Problem Is Still the Problem, Real or Perceived
This is the part I’d rather you take away from all of this. Whether the affordability gap right now is entirely real, meaning the math genuinely doesn’t work at current prices and rates for a lot of households, or partly perceived, meaning buyers are anchoring to 2021 rates and prices that were never going to last, the effect on the market is the same either way. People are hesitating. Sales are slow. Inventory is piling up because buyers aren’t pulling the trigger at the pace sellers expect.
It doesn’t matter much whether the hesitation comes from a genuine budget constraint or a mental one built around what rates and prices used to be. Both keep a buyer on the sidelines. Both show up in the same sales numbers.
Set Your Ceiling Before You Shop
With more inventory and more negotiating room than we’ve had in years, the smartest thing a buyer can do is know their real number before they start touring homes, not after they’ve fallen for one that was always going to be a stretch.
Run your actual numbers through the Total Mortgage Payment and Cash to Close Calculator at today’s rate, with your state’s real tax and insurance costs built in, before you start asking for seller credits on a house that doesn’t fit your budget to begin with. If you’re trying to decide whether this is actually a better time to buy than it feels like, the Rent vs. Buy Calculator is worth running too.
This ties directly into something I wrote a few weeks ago about pending sales falling and Dallas prices going negative. That piece made the case that fear, not math, is what’s keeping a lot of buyers out of a market that actually has more room to negotiate than it’s had in years. This week’s numbers back that up. If you want to see how closely our estimates track real lender quotes before you commit to anything, the accuracy case study on this site walks through it.
The Bottom Line
The market has more homes on it than it’s had in a decade, and that’s a good, healthy, normal thing, not a warning sign. Sales are still slow because the payment math, real or perceived, is still the obstacle for a lot of buyers. More choice helps. It isn’t a substitute for knowing your number.
Figure out what you can actually afford before you start shopping the extra inventory, and use the leverage you do have on a home that was going to work for you anyway.
Don Proctor has 37 years of experience in commercial banking, mortgage lending, and credit analysis. Your Mortgage Toolbox was built from that background to give buyers accurate, state-specific payment estimates before they sit down with a lender.